The Stormwater Blogs

The Blogger

Janice Kaspersen Janice Kaspersen Stormwater Editor

More from this blogger

  1. Dead Zones
  2. Five Years On
  3. Closer Together
  4. Thanks to the StormCon Moderators!
  5. Dam Breach in Iowa
  6. Two Weeks to StormCon
  7. Mosquitoes and Malaria
  8. More Mosquitoes
  9. Storms in the Gulf
  10. Seeking StormCon Moderators
  11. Never Flooded Before
  12. Storms in the Midwest
  13. Restoring the Penobscot
  14. Hurricanes and Oil
  15. The Uninvited
  16. Half of Our Trees Are Missing
  17. A Hairy Solution
  18. Oil in the Gulf
  19. A Multitalented Plant
  20. Where It Falls
  21. Floating BMPs
  22. Regulating Copper in Brake Pads
  23. EPA Addresses Water Contaminants
  24. Getting Along With the Neighbors
  25. Local Voices in Washington
  26. Out of Sight
  27. Sentinel Species
  28. Collection System
  29. Living Underground
  30. Keeping Stormwater Onsite in LA
  31. Appealing the New Flood Maps
  32. EPA Sets Nutrient Limits for Florida
  33. Some Like It Hot
  34. Skip the Bag, Save the River
  35. Maintenance The Unglamorous Necessity
  36. Put the LID on Stormwater
  37. Federal Responsibility for Katrina Flooding
  38. Certifying Performance
  39. EPA's Construction Effluent Guidelines Released
  40. StormCon Abstracts Due December 2
  41. Reclassified
  42. Reusing Runoff
  43. More Than Just Pipes
  44. Two Announcements from EPA
  45. Separation Anxiety
  46. Federal Funding for Local Projects
  47. Undoing Progress
  48. StormCon 2010 Call for Papers
  49. A Decimal Point Makes a Difference
  50. Lovely as a Tree
  51. Stimulus Funds and Stormwater
  52. Thanks to the StormCon Session Moderators!
  53. Live From StormCon..
  54. StormCon '09 More You Should Know About
  55. Counting Beach Closures
  56. Still Growing
  57. Density Done Well
  58. A Combination Problem
  59. One Driveway at a Time
  60. Underground
  61. Making Sure Infrastructure Doesn't Become a Hazard
  62. A Beach Comes Back
  63. With a Grain of Salt
  64. Blocking Out the Storm
  65. LID in Washington State
  66. Florida Gains Land in Public-Private Partnership
  67. A High-Density Debate
  68. Stormwater Management in Plain Sight
  69. Charging More for Potential Pollutants
  70. At Home in the Watershed
  71. We Have Met the Polluter - He Is Us
  72. Mobile Car Wash Runoff
  73. Red River Rising
  74. Summer School
  75. Rain Barrels, Anyone
  76. Getting Serious About the Weather
  77. Taking the Pulse of Utilities
  78. Not Your Ordinary Utility Debate
  79. How Dangerous Is Chitosan, Really Do We Need Certification
  80. Debating Dollars
  81. Demonstrating Green
  82. Paperless Stormwater
  83. Looking for Shovel-Ready Projects
  84. Online Erosion Control Training - Let Us Know What You Think
  85. No Relief Yet for the Northwest
  86. Happy Holidays From Stormwater
  87. Remedying Retention Pond Dangers
  88. New Funding on the Way
  89. The Case of the Missing Manhole Cover
  90. StormCon '09 Abstracts Are Due December 3
  91. A New Plan in the Everglades
  92. Down the Drain
  93. Gunk in the Ocean Our Problem
  94. Save the Date December 3 Is Closer Than You Think
  95. Watershed-Based Permitting
  96. Looking Outside Our Own Backyard
  97. The Clean Watersheds Needs Survey
  98. Show Me the Money, If You Can Find It
  99. The Safety Issue
  100. StormCon '09 Call for Papers
  101. Worse Weather Or Does It Just Seem That Way
  102. Gustav a Reminder of What's Left To Do
  103. Recovering After the Storm
  104. Who Owns the Rain
  105. How Are Your Pipes
  106. Regulations We've Got Those Covered, Too
  107. You Asked for BMPs - We've Got 'Em
  108. Simplifying Public Outreach
  109. New Terminology
  110. Buying Time and Space for the Everglades
  111. The Worst Is Over
  112. Midwest Flooding - Could This Have Happened Differently
  113. EPA's Message to Homebuilders
  114. StormCon '08 Is Less Than Two Months Away
  115. Welcome to our new Website!
  116. The State of Water Quality
view all

SW Editor's Blog

August 11th, 2008 6:46am PST

BMPs and the Bigger Picture

Posted By Janice Kaspersen 5 Comments

“BMPs and the Bigger Picture” was the subject of one of the panel discussions at StormCon last week in Orlando. Five panelists—Bill Hunt from North Carolina State University; Andrew Reese of AMEC Earth & Environmental; Robert Roseen from the University of New Hampshire’s Stormwater Center; Tom Schueler, founder of the Center for Watershed Protection and currently the coordinator of the Chesapeake Stormwater Network; and Nikos Singelis of the USEPA—addressed a number of questions about where stormwater BMPs are headed.

Among the questions prepared by Andy Reese, the panel moderator, was what will affect the development of BMPs over the next five years, and what should people be doing now to prepare their programs for the changes ahead. The panelists took turns throwing out ideas, a couple dozen in all, and the audience of about 200 voted on them. Some panelists thought we’ll be taking a more holistic approach to BMPs, looking at the entire watershed and focusing more on the effects of BMPs on habitat. Some said that life-cycle maintenance costs—not just purchase or installation costs—will have much greater influence, especially as we develop a better idea over time of what those costs really are. (Probably the most welcome answer, though, came from Tom Schueler, who predicted the term “BMP” itself will meet its demise in the next five years.)

We gave you a chance before the conference to submit questions for the panel. Here’s your chance to provide some answers, if you weren’t part of the onsite audience. What do you think will be the most significant trends affecting BMPs?

 

What Do You Think?

Post a Comment

Gordon

August 26th, 2008 11:03 AM PT

Sometimes we lose track of the other side of stormwater, that pesky flooding and volume problem. It was brought back to light last week in Florida with record rains of 12" - 32" in many areas. Most of the masterplanning and retrofit projects I have built over the years were to address flooding first and water quality second. For new development, LID will lead to smaller ponds, but you still need ponds (BMPs) to stop flooding and match those pre vs post discharge rates. LID will not offset that. To retrofit old built out areas in downtown areas, ditches, pipes, and regional lakes are the only way to reduce flooding, and oh yeah- provide some water quality. Those type of BMPs are here to stay. As Eric Livingston says - Flooding drives the bus.

billragen

September 9th, 2008 10:28 AM PT

Perhaps the biggest change that I see coming will be the increased use of porous pavements (PP) and infiltration practices. Many of the problems associated with PP are being dealt with and new technology such as FilterPave is coming fast. Preventing or minimizing runoff is less expensive than dealing with it at the end of a pipe.

Chris@estesdesign.com

August 13th, 2008 11:00 AM PT

I agree the that change begins with experience. Projects should involve key water quality design specialists. Unfortunately the regulators are dragging behind the science and have caused some stagnation in the past.

esph2ogp

August 25th, 2008 8:43 AM PT

Greater quantity and quality of BMP monitoring data should have a significant influence on BMP development in the next five years. Localities that are now coming into compliance with NPDES Phase 2 will significantly enlarge the knowledge base of BMP effectiveness relative to the wide varieties of climates and soils where they are applied.

tom hegemier

August 13th, 2008 9:37 AM PT

To see significant change in water quality protection features (I agree, the term BMP should go away), there needs to be more experienced stormwater designers that can create plans to distribute stormwater management throughout the site, instead of relying on end-of-pipe techniques. It's easy for engineers to pull the standard designs from the CAD library and drop them into the plans and being a competitive engineering marketplace, it can be challenging to deviate from this business model. Running hand-in-hand with this is more flexibility from the regulating agencies to adopt distributed stormwater management criteria to ensure a more certain permitting process for all parties.

Post a Comment

Not a subscriber? Sign Up
 
 
*  
 




 

Get Stormwater E-mail Updates!

Get weekly news and updates through our Stormwater e-mail newsletter!